Great North Circular Road?
Moderator: Site Management Team
Great North Circular Road?
Just heard a traffic report on Radio 5 Live referring to the "Great North Circular Road". What?
Bet they wouldn't have made that mistake when they were based in London
Bet they wouldn't have made that mistake when they were based in London
- roadtester
- Member
- Posts: 31475
- Joined: Mon Mar 26, 2007 18:05
- Location: Cambridgeshire
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Perhaps not - but it just balances out the howlers of London-based broadcasters when mentioning provincial English/Welsh/Scottish/Northern Irish locations...Brock wrote:Just heard a traffic report on Radio 5 Live referring to the "Great North Circular Road". What?
Bet they wouldn't have made that mistake when they were based in London
Re: Great North Circular Road?
I can assure you that there are just as many gross blunders done by London travel broadcasters about their own location.roadtester wrote: Perhaps not - but it just balances out the howlers of London-based broadcasters when mentioning provincial English/Welsh/Scottish/Northern Irish locations...
A classic was when there were a series of cancellations on the Shoeburyness to Fenchurch Street railway one morning. "And .... uh .... the following trains like is cancelled. 0645 Sness to F Street. 0715 Sness to F Street. 0745 Sness to F Street .....".
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Yep, that's what happens when young, badly or untrained people do announcements. Rail announcements that talk of a train station. Station will do.
Roads and holidays in the west, before motorways.
http://trektothewest.shutterfly.com
http://holidayroads.webs.com/
http://trektothewest.shutterfly.com
http://holidayroads.webs.com/
Re: Great North Circular Road?
I realise we're drifting from the topic now, but the one that really grates on me is most often heard on the Tube, though I've heard it on the railways as well - an announcement that a train will be "non stopping" at a particular station.SteveA30 wrote:Yep, that's what happens when young, badly or untrained people do announcements. Rail announcements that talk of a train station. Station will do.
That's jargon and can be replaced with something that is just as short and with no change to the surrounding grammar - "not stopping".
Chris
Roads.org.uk
Roads.org.uk
-
- Account deactivated at user request
- Posts: 2939
- Joined: Sat Sep 05, 2009 10:22
- Location: n/a
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Topic has now suffered a double blowout to the offside and has barrel-rolled over the crash barrier into oncoming traffic.Chris5156 wrote: I realise we're drifting from the topic now, but the one that really grates on me is most often heard on the Tube, though I've heard it on the railways as well - an announcement that a train will be "non stopping" at a particular station.
That's jargon and can be replaced with something that is just as short and with no change to the surrounding grammar - "not stopping".
The 'into' grates on me every time I am on the train.We are now arriving into Macclesfield
..
- PeterA5145
- Member
- Posts: 25347
- Joined: Sun Mar 24, 2002 00:19
- Location: Stockport, Cheshire
- Contact:
Re: Great North Circular Road?
I was just about to post that onechris486 wrote:The 'into' grates on me every time I am on the train.We are now arriving into Macclesfield
“The human race divides politically into those who want people to be controlled and those who have no such desire.” – Robert A. Heinlein
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Back to trivia, and a regular issue in London is giving out road numbers which are not in any common usage. For example, "Heavy traffic on the A4202 southbound", when there is hardly a user of that main route who knows it by its number. Do other places suffer from the same ?
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Well, not quite. You need to switch round the words "be" and "not" as well.Chris5156 wrote: I realise we're drifting from the topic now, but the one that really grates on me is most often heard on the Tube, though I've heard it on the railways as well - an announcement that a train will be "non stopping" at a particular station.
That's jargon and can be replaced with something that is just as short and with no change to the surrounding grammar - "not stopping".
Re: Great North Circular Road?
The light has dawned. It was to distinguish it from the Pathetic South Circular Road.Brock wrote:Just heard a traffic report on Radio 5 Live referring to the "Great North Circular Road".
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Yes! "The Asomething is closed between its junction with Bgodknowswhat and the Roadyouveneverheardof".WHBM wrote:Back to trivia, and a regular issue in London is giving out road numbers which are not in any common usage. For example, "Heavy traffic on the A4202 southbound", when there is hardly a user of that main route who knows it by its number. Do other places suffer from the same ?
Re: Great North Circular Road?
As I recently wrote in another thread, the A1 matrix signs are terrible for this in S Yorks/Notts
They tend to say "Delays after A6xx" or "Road closed after A6xx" when most people would know junctions generally by their names or the towns they pass at this stretch. This is helped less by some of the numbers either meeting with more than once or multiplexing with the A1
Redhouse=A638
Marr=A635
J36=A630
Blyth=A614
Blyth (s)=A634
Ranby = A620
Apleyhead=A614(again) /A57
Markham moor=A638 (again) /A57 (again)
They tend to say "Delays after A6xx" or "Road closed after A6xx" when most people would know junctions generally by their names or the towns they pass at this stretch. This is helped less by some of the numbers either meeting with more than once or multiplexing with the A1
Redhouse=A638
Marr=A635
J36=A630
Blyth=A614
Blyth (s)=A634
Ranby = A620
Apleyhead=A614(again) /A57
Markham moor=A638 (again) /A57 (again)
Is there a road improvement project going on near you? Help us to document it on the SABRE Wiki - help is available in the Digest forum.
Have you browsed SABRE Maps recently? Get involved! - see our guide to scanning and stitching maps
Have you browsed SABRE Maps recently? Get involved! - see our guide to scanning and stitching maps
Re: Great North Circular Road?
That's the Highways Agency's national policy - on non-motorways the matrix signs will refer to road numbers. The problem with using names is that they don't always appear on signs, so you might know that the A638 junction is called Redhouse but there's nothing at the junction itself to tell you that. Road numbers might be tricky but at least they do appear on signs.c2R wrote:As I recently wrote in another thread, the A1 matrix signs are terrible for this in S Yorks/Notts
They tend to say "Delays after A6xx" or "Road closed after A6xx" when most people would know junctions generally by their names or the towns they pass at this stretch. This is helped less by some of the numbers either meeting with more than once or multiplexing with the A1
Redhouse=A638
Marr=A635
J36=A630
Blyth=A614
Blyth (s)=A634
Ranby = A620
Apleyhead=A614(again) /A57
Markham moor=A638 (again) /A57 (again)
One alternative might be to refer to large towns instead - so rather than referring to Markham Moor, you could say "between Doncaster and Newark". That would be very easily understood but you must sacrifice some precision to make it work.
Chris
Roads.org.uk
Roads.org.uk
- Mark Hewitt
- Member
- Posts: 31410
- Joined: Fri Dec 17, 2004 12:54
- Location: Chester-le-Street
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Doesn't always work eg if it says road closed after A167 when it meets the A1 several times.
Re: Great North Circular Road?
A27 closed after A259 is common.
We'll sometimes get
A3 closed after A283
and sometimes get
A3 closed Hindhead Tunnel
We'll sometimes get
A3 closed after A283
and sometimes get
A3 closed Hindhead Tunnel
Re: Great North Circular Road?
One that caught me out yesterday was the radio announcing that Roughcote Lane (Weston Coyney) was closed following an accident, what they failed to mention is that the Police had actually closed the A520 as well (no one knows why) so everyone tried to use the A520 to avoid Roughcote Lane and caused a 3 mile tailback.
Living my life on the edge......of two counties!
Formerly known as Roverman
Still driving a British built car, made in a former Rover factory......
Formerly known as Roverman
Still driving a British built car, made in a former Rover factory......
- hoagy_ytfc
- Member
- Posts: 632
- Joined: Sun May 23, 2010 00:10
Re: Great North Circular Road?
In fairness, that would be a bad announcement, as people would lose faith in the announcements if it subsequently stopped there (e.g. for signal check).wrinkly wrote:Or "will not stop at".
"not scheduled to stop at" works better.
And it's what is usually used, IME.
- hoagy_ytfc
- Member
- Posts: 632
- Joined: Sun May 23, 2010 00:10
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Not sure why people are fussed about radio announcements, they're usually so far out-of-date.
Your (*) satnav live updates will be way more accurate and up-to-date.
Order of reliability, ISTM:
1. TomTom HD Traffic *
2. Radio
3. Guesswork
4. Overhead signs
* I can only personally vouch for TomTom HD traffic, but I imagine others are good too.
Your (*) satnav live updates will be way more accurate and up-to-date.
Order of reliability, ISTM:
1. TomTom HD Traffic *
2. Radio
3. Guesswork
4. Overhead signs
* I can only personally vouch for TomTom HD traffic, but I imagine others are good too.
Re: Great North Circular Road?
Not as bad as "pass to Caerphilly", which translates as calling at Cardiff Queen Street, then skipping Heath High Level, Llanisien, and Lisvane and Thornhill, despite the former two of those three having the highest counter-peak ridership on the line (and if Arriva weren't totally incompetent, they'd just turn those late Bargoed trains short at Ystrad Mynach to make up the time instead).Chris5156 wrote:I realise we're drifting from the topic now, but the one that really grates on me is most often heard on the Tube, though I've heard it on the railways as well - an announcement that a train will be "non stopping" at a particular station.