A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Moderator: Site Management Team
A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
I recently drove the A11 between the A14 & A47 Norwich southern bypass. I knew the remaining sections had been dualed & some roundabouts remained, particularly at either end of the Thetford bypass. However, I didn't realise that they were not alone. I guess there are about five or six? Are there any plans to remove any these over the coming years?
Prior to completion of the A11 schemes I am sure Norwich had the distinction of being one of the largest places (if not the largest?) without a 'complete' dual carriageway link to other places in the UK? The roundabouts seemed like a barrier to 'expressway status', but perhaps we shouldn't mention that? Any thoughts?
Prior to completion of the A11 schemes I am sure Norwich had the distinction of being one of the largest places (if not the largest?) without a 'complete' dual carriageway link to other places in the UK? The roundabouts seemed like a barrier to 'expressway status', but perhaps we shouldn't mention that? Any thoughts?
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Thetford's a isolated problem which will take major investment to solve the 5 junctions of this stretch but agree the two roundabouts further out (Five ways and the other one towards Norwich) could be quite easily be made free flow and should be done as soon as possible. With these gone Thetford would then quickly be seen as the missing link and pressure would grow to get this final stretch improved.
I see a solution here being to reduce the number of junctions down to 2 then making these free flow completing the link to the M11.
I see a solution here being to reduce the number of junctions down to 2 then making these free flow completing the link to the M11.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
The one near Attleborough was to be a GSJ when the section between there and Thetford was dualled but it was changed to a roundabout at the 11th hour. Does anyone know why?
How would you like your grade separations, Sir?
Big and complex.
Big and complex.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
I would guess to save money or placate objectors?
Yes, although now fully dualed, this section of the A11 reminded me of the A1 before the 6 roundabouts were GSJ'd several years ago.thomas417 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 07, 2020 11:56 Thetford's a isolated problem which will take major investment to solve the 5 junctions of this stretch but agree the two roundabouts further out (Five ways and the other one towards Norwich) could be quite easily be made free flow and should be done as soon as possible. With these gone Thetford would then quickly be seen as the missing link and pressure would grow to get this final stretch improved. I see a solution here being to reduce the number of junctions down to 2 then making these free flow completing the link to the M11.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Fiveways is in the pipeline for RIS3. Nothing else is in the programme.
The silliest thing at Thetford is actually the GSJ, which makes it hard to grade separate the adjacent rbt. Should have just been a bridge.
The silliest thing at Thetford is actually the GSJ, which makes it hard to grade separate the adjacent rbt. Should have just been a bridge.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Fiveways really should have been sorted out properly when they did the dualling of the A11 there about 5 years ago. It could only have been a cost issue.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Only in the UK would a piddling unclassified road that simply didn't need slip roads at all get a parclo whilst a more strategic A road gets a roundabout.
Bryn
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Had a quick go at what I'd do at Thetford, reducing the number of junctions down to 2 GSJ's (red dots) serving both halves of the town. Surely enough access points for a town this size and provides sufficient spacing between junctions for a road with Expressway ambitions.
Removed are the existing at grade roundabouts with the A134/B1107 and the A1075 Norwich Road with the A11 flying under or over these roads and slips removed from the low standard GSJ with Croxton Road.
Removed are the existing at grade roundabouts with the A134/B1107 and the A1075 Norwich Road with the A11 flying under or over these roads and slips removed from the low standard GSJ with Croxton Road.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
The Norwich Road junction could be a LILO so traffic from Norwich entering Thetford can still use the existing road.
How would you like your grade separations, Sir?
Big and complex.
Big and complex.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
does the Fiveways potential scheme also include grade separation of the junctions between there and Red Lodge?
- Burwellian
- Member
- Posts: 531
- Joined: Thu Mar 20, 2008 02:28
- Location: Cheshire
- Contact:
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Say you're heading from Bury SE to Swaffham... How would you like to get from the A134 to the A134?thomas417 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 07, 2020 17:49 Had a quick go at what I'd do at Thetford, reducing the number of junctions down to 2 GSJ's (red dots) serving both halves of the town. Surely enough access points for a town this size and provides sufficient spacing between junctions for a road with Expressway ambitions.
Could do a new build single carriageway alongside the A11 perhaps?
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Redesignate the A134 number to London Road. Sorted.Burwellian wrote: ↑Mon Sep 07, 2020 19:19Say you're heading from Bury SE to Swaffham... How would you like to get from the A134 to the A134?thomas417 wrote: ↑Mon Sep 07, 2020 17:49 Had a quick go at what I'd do at Thetford, reducing the number of junctions down to 2 GSJ's (red dots) serving both halves of the town. Surely enough access points for a town this size and provides sufficient spacing between junctions for a road with Expressway ambitions.
Could do a new build single carriageway alongside the A11 perhaps?
Make poetry history.
Did you know there's more to SABRE than just the Forums?
Help with maps using the new online calibrator.
Add your roads knowledge to the SABRE Wiki.
Did you know there's more to SABRE than just the Forums?
Help with maps using the new online calibrator.
Add your roads knowledge to the SABRE Wiki.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Or this which avoids the need to drive into town and back outBig L wrote: ↑Mon Sep 07, 2020 19:35Redesignate the A134 number to London Road. Sorted.Burwellian wrote: ↑Mon Sep 07, 2020 19:19 Say you're heading from Bury SE to Swaffham... How would you like to get from the A134 to the A134?
Could do a new build single carriageway alongside the A11 perhaps?
How would you like your grade separations, Sir?
Big and complex.
Big and complex.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Removing direct access from the A1075 to the A11 could create problems as traffic from mid Norfolk, including Dereham and Watton, would have to go (almost) into Thetford and back up the A1066 past various industrial estates to head to London etc. Also there is a lot of housing development ongoing on the A1075 between the town and the A11 so Norwich bound traffic from here would also have to head back towards the town and use the A1066.
The B1107 junction is perhaps less of an issue if the southern link suggested for the A134 was to be built* but it would still mean Brandon to Norwich traffic having to go in and back out of Thetford.
It's the A11/A134(N) /A1066 roundbout which causes the main problems at the moment, the other roundabouts seem to cope reasonably well. But if this junction was GSJ'd I expect the delays would be transferred elsewhere as happened after the Elveden bypass was opened, before this there wasn't much congestion at this roundabout as traffic was being held up further south.
(*regrdless of any improvements to the Thetford bypass this needs to be done anyway as there is a southbound weight restiction on the A134 from the B1107 roundabout with HGVs sent along the A11 (and ex-A11) to an unclassified road between Elveden and Barnham)
The B1107 junction is perhaps less of an issue if the southern link suggested for the A134 was to be built* but it would still mean Brandon to Norwich traffic having to go in and back out of Thetford.
It's the A11/A134(N) /A1066 roundbout which causes the main problems at the moment, the other roundabouts seem to cope reasonably well. But if this junction was GSJ'd I expect the delays would be transferred elsewhere as happened after the Elveden bypass was opened, before this there wasn't much congestion at this roundabout as traffic was being held up further south.
(*regrdless of any improvements to the Thetford bypass this needs to be done anyway as there is a southbound weight restiction on the A134 from the B1107 roundabout with HGVs sent along the A11 (and ex-A11) to an unclassified road between Elveden and Barnham)
- Mapper89062
- Member
- Posts: 167
- Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2021 21:25
- Location: on your map
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
So it seems that improving the A11 Fiveways roundabout is now on, at a cost of £101m, which ought to pay for some grade separation, though I'm not quite sure what the plan is - it depends on whether all the service areas need to stay and how important local access is.
Here's my design, which utilises as much of the existing layout as possible, provides full local access, and maintains most of the service areas with just one bridge:
Burger King and the petrol station just fit between the new and old A11 alignments - Travelodge would have to be demolished and relocated, for which I left the stub on the eastern LAR as an access point. An additional bridge might be needed to replace the reserve gaps at the other end of the Barton Mills bypass.
Here's my design, which utilises as much of the existing layout as possible, provides full local access, and maintains most of the service areas with just one bridge:
Burger King and the petrol station just fit between the new and old A11 alignments - Travelodge would have to be demolished and relocated, for which I left the stub on the eastern LAR as an access point. An additional bridge might be needed to replace the reserve gaps at the other end of the Barton Mills bypass.
Just your average mapper, bringing you a map-focused take on today's world
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Here's a presentation on Fiveways from January: https://www.suffolkchamber.co.uk/media/ ... tation.pdf
There are no details about design but a couple of tidbits: "If selected for delivery, construction of this scheme will likely start in 2028" and "Public consultation preparation – likely to be held in Summer 2022" (probably now delayed).
I should also belatedly say that I agree with Mapper's basic design. It may be better to demolish Burger King and Esso as well to remove the need for long retaining walls or a viaduct next to them. In any case it may not be financially viable for Esso, BP and Shell to all be accessed off the same dumbbell roundabout.
There are no details about design but a couple of tidbits: "If selected for delivery, construction of this scheme will likely start in 2028" and "Public consultation preparation – likely to be held in Summer 2022" (probably now delayed).
I should also belatedly say that I agree with Mapper's basic design. It may be better to demolish Burger King and Esso as well to remove the need for long retaining walls or a viaduct next to them. In any case it may not be financially viable for Esso, BP and Shell to all be accessed off the same dumbbell roundabout.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Well that was a wasted opportunity, all it adds up to is 'hey traffic is bad there we should do something, we'll go away and think about it.'jackal wrote: ↑Fri Aug 19, 2022 12:23 Here's a presentation on Fiveways from January: https://www.suffolkchamber.co.uk/media/ ... tation.pdf
There are no details about design but a couple of tidbits: "If selected for delivery, construction of this scheme will likely start in 2028" and "Public consultation preparation – likely to be held in Summer 2022" (probably now delayed).
I should also belatedly say that I agree with Mapper's basic design. It may be better to demolish Burger King and Esso as well to remove the need for long retaining walls or a viaduct next to them. In any case it may not be financially viable for Esso, BP and Shell to all be accessed off the same dumbbell roundabout.
They tried just signalising it what is the betting that the next effort will be a hamburger ? There is a McDonalds after all Ideally they would remove ALL the businesses on the roundabout and build a separate service area but they won't pay for that so whatever happens will be another bodge.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
^ The budget is £101m as per the DfT pipeline. I assume it's a grade separation scheme.
-
- Member
- Posts: 1419
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 07:52
- Location: Exits 9 & 10, M1 East, Melbourne, Australia
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
Fiveways looks worthwhile treating. I won't comment on the suggested design above, since it's guesswork so far.
However, the four roundabouts actually on the Thetford Bypass: what's the hurry or the justification? They don't look (on google maps) very congested. We should accept that every DC doesn't need to be an 'expressway'. The only drivers for upgrades should be congestion, other symptoms of low level of service, or safety. To quote an often-voiced piece of Sabre common-sense: there are many other places on the strategic road network awaiting funding.
However, the four roundabouts actually on the Thetford Bypass: what's the hurry or the justification? They don't look (on google maps) very congested. We should accept that every DC doesn't need to be an 'expressway'. The only drivers for upgrades should be congestion, other symptoms of low level of service, or safety. To quote an often-voiced piece of Sabre common-sense: there are many other places on the strategic road network awaiting funding.
Re: A11 roundabouts towards Norwich
The answer is best discovered in Sabre Maps, Thetford has had huge growth around the periphery made possible by the bypass. If you are trying to get from say the Thetford Academy to Castle Street its a real pain. Traffic congestion in the town is normal and you dont want HGV's in there.Peter Freeman wrote: ↑Fri Aug 19, 2022 15:54 Fiveways looks worthwhile treating. I won't comment on the suggested design above, since it's guesswork so far.
However, the four roundabouts actually on the Thetford Bypass: what's the hurry or the justification? They don't look (on google maps) very congested. We should accept that every DC doesn't need to be an 'expressway'. The only drivers for upgrades should be congestion, other symptoms of low level of service, or safety. To quote an often-voiced piece of Sabre common-sense: there are many other places on the strategic road network awaiting funding.
Use the Map fader here to see growth since 1963
https://www.sabre-roads.org.uk/maps/ind ... 14&layer=0
Google Traffic
https://www.google.co.uk/maps/dir/52.42 ... !1e1?hl=en
Its not really a bypass any more - its a ring road and new developments are still being built.