A38 Derby Junctions
Moderator: Site Management Team
A38 Derby Junctions
Hi,
I travel through Derby daily at the moment using the A38 and am interested in the Highways Agency's proposals for the three roundabouts. Personally I've never really had a problem at kings way, and this junction could be improved by signalising all approaches. Markeaton really needs to be replaced with an underpass or flyover and some sort of improvement is also required at little eaton. Maybe again the signals need to be made full time and the roundabout made larger.
I'll be interested to hear other people's views on these junctions!!
I travel through Derby daily at the moment using the A38 and am interested in the Highways Agency's proposals for the three roundabouts. Personally I've never really had a problem at kings way, and this junction could be improved by signalising all approaches. Markeaton really needs to be replaced with an underpass or flyover and some sort of improvement is also required at little eaton. Maybe again the signals need to be made full time and the roundabout made larger.
I'll be interested to hear other people's views on these junctions!!
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
Definitely needed, but doesn't look likely to happen any time soon. A package of improvements is to begin shortly, but nothing major.
A38 Derby Junctions
I did some work on them in 1999... Nothing happened yet, don't hold ya breath... Grade separated would be great, but to be perfectly honest, getting rid of the three roundabouts and replacing with carefully considered large scale high capacity signal controlled junctions would help tremendously, would be a lot cheaper, create less blight and keep local residents happier.
-
- Member
- Posts: 1040
- Joined: Sat Dec 28, 2002 21:16
- Location: Walsall Wood, WALSALL, West Midlands
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
How about a scheme where only the A5111 and A61 roundabouts are grade-separated, with the A52 Ashbourne Road being bridged over or under and another link road provided to link the A52 to the A5111 junction?
Chris Williams
Chris Williams
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
To be fair, I think access to the Markeaton Roundabout from the A38 is the least important of the three. If you're coming into Derby from the North, you'd use the A61, from the South the A516. Access to the Mackworth Estate and the New Zealand (still not convinced that's its proper name) area is given by that junction between Kingsway and Markeaton, so bridging the A52 over/under the A38 there might make sense. The only thing which would be really lost is easy access to Markeaton Park.
- Roadtripper_Ian
- Member
- Posts: 7064
- Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2002 21:14
- Location: Central Buchan
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
I take it from looking at the layout of the southern roundabout that grade separation was envisaged, but what was the plan for the northern roundabout?
"I don't make the rules, ma'am, I just make them up and write them down"
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
swarkestonecauseway wrote: New Zealand (still not convinced that's its proper name)
There you go https://maps.google.co.uk/maps?q=New+Ze ... 75,,0,5.74
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
That's the most important one of the lot! Well, it was when I was a kid anyway, Markeaton Park was probably second to Alton Towers on my list of places to go.swarkestonecauseway wrote:The only thing which would be really lost is easy access to Markeaton Park.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
I'd be intrigued as to traffic numbers. What the split of traffic coming down the A38 is, wrt going into to Derby, vs going round Derby. Always seemed when I made a semi-regular trip between Sheffield and Brum/Nuneaton, that the Markeaton roundabout was the worse. It also always seemed that most traffic, like me, was sticking to the A38 throughout.swarkestonecauseway wrote:To be fair, I think access to the Markeaton Roundabout from the A38 is the least important of the three. If you're coming into Derby from the North, you'd use the A61, from the South the A516. Access to the Mackworth Estate and the New Zealand (still not convinced that's its proper name) area is given by that junction between Kingsway and Markeaton, so bridging the A52 over/under the A38 there might make sense. The only thing which would be really lost is easy access to Markeaton Park.
It does seem like that roundabout is crying out for an overpass/Underpass.
Nic
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
It always seemed to have an appeal disproportionately high for what it wasHelvellyn wrote:That's the most important one of the lot! Well, it was when I was a kid anyway, Markeaton Park was probably second to Alton Towers on my list of places to go.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
There have been several schemes mooted over the past 20 years to my knowledge, particularly for the Markeaton roundabout which seems to create the most frustration although the Little Eaton roundabout can be bad for A61 traffic - queues all the way back to Pentagon and beyond sometimes, although to be fair there are other junctions along the length which affect traffic flows. I've never seen a satisfactory solution yet that gives any benefit sufficient to justify the cost, even when we (as the County Council) had responsibility for the Trunk Roads.
My over-riding concern now is that any "solution" will be at the expense of the City roads - A61, A52 especially as the HA and their agents seem hell bent on improving their network without any concern for the adjacent non-trunk roads despite saying all the right things (network management, yeah right!). I've lost count of the numbers of times I've mentioned the problems they created with this blinkered policy - for those in the area shall I just mention the M1 J25 and the road to Long Eaton in the evening peak, you know what I'm saying.
My over-riding concern now is that any "solution" will be at the expense of the City roads - A61, A52 especially as the HA and their agents seem hell bent on improving their network without any concern for the adjacent non-trunk roads despite saying all the right things (network management, yeah right!). I've lost count of the numbers of times I've mentioned the problems they created with this blinkered policy - for those in the area shall I just mention the M1 J25 and the road to Long Eaton in the evening peak, you know what I'm saying.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
A lot of the appeal vanished when I fell in that disgusting lake in the playground area.swarkestonecauseway wrote:It always seemed to have an appeal disproportionately high for what it wasHelvellyn wrote:That's the most important one of the lot! Well, it was when I was a kid anyway, Markeaton Park was probably second to Alton Towers on my list of places to go.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
Everyone in Derby must have done that in their youth . I've done it as well.
- marknotgeorge
- Member
- Posts: 208
- Joined: Sat Aug 12, 2006 20:08
- Location: Derby
- Contact:
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
I use Markeaton and Kingsway islands everyday on my way to work in Burton, living not very far at all from Markeaton Park. Going to work, I find that congestion is worst when traffic backs up along Ashbourne Road (A52 into the city), mainly caused by people who can't comprehend what the KEEP CLEAR markings in the road mean.
Kingsway island's not too bad, but Kingsway itself could definitely be improved be reinstating the two lanes up the hill to the retail park. The congestion from the retail park is caused by people insisting on turning right into Currys, which is a movement I'd prevent.
Unless you're planning dirty great flyovers, and I have trouble seeing where one's going to fit at Markeaton to be honest, Haydn's traffic lights idea seems good. They seem to have worked at the Cockpit.
Oh, and that lake in Mundy Play Centre (named after the family that owned Markeaton Hall)? I seem to recall it being drained last time I was there. It was truly rank.
Kingsway island's not too bad, but Kingsway itself could definitely be improved be reinstating the two lanes up the hill to the retail park. The congestion from the retail park is caused by people insisting on turning right into Currys, which is a movement I'd prevent.
Unless you're planning dirty great flyovers, and I have trouble seeing where one's going to fit at Markeaton to be honest, Haydn's traffic lights idea seems good. They seem to have worked at the Cockpit.
Oh, and that lake in Mundy Play Centre (named after the family that owned Markeaton Hall)? I seem to recall it being drained last time I was there. It was truly rank.
--
Mark, Derby, UK.
Doing sums for a living since 2009...
Mark, Derby, UK.
Doing sums for a living since 2009...
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
Yeah it was. The last of the family donated the land to the people of Derby.marknotgeorge wrote:Oh, and that lake in Mundy Play Centre (named after the family that owned Markeaton Hall)? I seem to recall it being drained last time I was there. It was truly rank.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
Yes. It's classic 'prisoners dilema'. Collectively everything would move faster if no-one turned right into Currys. But individually once you have queued up behind all the other right turners, you are better off turning right yourself.marknotgeorge wrote: Kingsway itself could definitely be improved be reinstating the two lanes up the hill to the retail park. The congestion from the retail park is caused by people insisting on turning right into Currys, which is a movement I'd prevent.
At the very least I'd ban right turns into Currys in the last few weeks before Christmas.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
Whatever they have planned for Markeaton roundabout, it has to include a new system of getting cars into/out of the garage/McDonalds alongside - it is a complete mess and there are daily occurences of very near misses as people get frustrated with not being able to get out onto the A52.
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
This would improve traffic flows during peak times, but at the expense of creating delays of several minutes at all other times.Haydn1971 wrote:to be perfectly honest, getting rid of the three roundabouts and replacing with carefully considered large scale high capacity signal controlled junctions would help tremendously, would be a lot cheaper, create less blight and keep local residents happier.
It reminds me of the junction at the southern end of the Gloucester Ring Road. When it was a roundabout, I must have travelled through this junction hundreds of times - in all diections, without once ever being held up for more than a few seconds. Then it was turned into one of these "high capacity signal controlled junctions", and now I get delayed for a couple of minutes every time I pass through it.
I do wonder whether someone could come up with a junction design that combines the best of both worlds. Using Gloucester as an example again, the Elmbridge Court roundabout and the Walls roundabout have part-time traffic lights. This has the significant benefit of avoiding pointless delays outside of peak hours, and I am amazed that this concept is not used more widely.
Graham
Re: A38 Derby Junctions
The irony is that your suggestion is in place on one of the Derby junctions, and we are all clammering for it to go