M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Moderator: Site Management Team
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Maybe I've missed something, but it's not very cycling-friendly is it, (although neither is the present layout !) ? Three roundabouts to negotiate on the proposed new Jn 1 M54 to keep to the old road. Then there is the absolutely horrendous roundabout proposal for Jn 11 M6 !
The new Jn 11 M6 involves the complete demolition of the existing bridges, and installation of two new ones on a larger diameter roundabout. Surely this must cost almost the same as putting in at least a part-free flow junction ? Can it be the same designer who was responsible for the dreadful Switch Island up near Liverpool !
Its yet another spatchcock, but a very expensive one !
The new Jn 11 M6 involves the complete demolition of the existing bridges, and installation of two new ones on a larger diameter roundabout. Surely this must cost almost the same as putting in at least a part-free flow junction ? Can it be the same designer who was responsible for the dreadful Switch Island up near Liverpool !
Its yet another spatchcock, but a very expensive one !
- Patrick Harper
- Member
- Posts: 3218
- Joined: Sat Jan 16, 2010 14:41
- Location: Wiltshire
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Well the current roundabout is only two lanes wide + footpaths, if the plan for the new roundabout is for a wider circular carriageway plus filter lanes then that's still an improvement, and a less disruptive one than full freeflow would be to the area. Assuming they've setup their traffic modelling software correctly and they're choosing a design with regards to the stats generated from that, it's probably fine.
Looks like the M54 J1 design separates trunk from local traffic so cycling around it should be less daunting despite making the journey three small roundabouts instead of one big one. These sorts of schemes tend to make the footpaths shared use as well for those who are really scared.
Looks like the M54 J1 design separates trunk from local traffic so cycling around it should be less daunting despite making the journey three small roundabouts instead of one big one. These sorts of schemes tend to make the footpaths shared use as well for those who are really scared.
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
The freeflow design bypassed the existing roundabout (see plan I posted on previous page). It would have been much less disruptive than the selected design, which requires demolition of the existing junction.Patrick Harper wrote: ↑Thu Jul 29, 2021 21:31 Well the current roundabout is only two lanes wide + footpaths, if the plan for the new roundabout is for a wider circular carriageway plus filter lanes then that's still an improvement, and a less disruptive one than full freeflow would be to the area. Assuming they've setup their traffic modelling software correctly and they're choosing a design with regards to the stats generated from that, it's probably fine.
Remarkably there are not even any freeflow filter lanes in the selected design, nor any potential for any as they've put the old A460 between the link road and north facing onslip.
You have a lot of faith in the software. It's not an objective judge but a slave to the selected parameters and inputs. Usually the target is to keep the junction within 'capacity' at peak times. This is defined so it can be (and with this design, is bound to be) achieved with substantial queues. Furthermore, offpeak and interpeak journey times are usually treated as a 'don't care'. See HE's own metastudy of dozens of pinchpoint schemes, which found that average journey times usually increased. The modelling is basically rigged to deliver this dire outcome of a massively wide, fully signalized roundabout.
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
This is true, but not good enough any more, IMO. Shared footpaths that are used for cyclists are a terrible compromise. HE has a vast budget and even dedicated spending for improvements to NMU provision; they should be working towards dedicated cycle facilities on all their schemes. That applies more than anywhere else in a situation like this where you’re going to see a whole junction ripped up and rebuilt - it’s an opportunity to make real improvements that won’t be repeated. Fail to provide properly for NMUs now and it will be difficult to ever add provision for them later.Patrick Harper wrote: ↑Thu Jul 29, 2021 21:31These sorts of schemes tend to make the footpaths shared use as well for those who are really scared.
Chris
Roads.org.uk
Roads.org.uk
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Let's be honest, and say that the proposals are not very good at all. The link should be motorway only and then NMC can be catered-for in a decent manner.
-
- Member
- Posts: 1208
- Joined: Thu Jun 25, 2015 13:14
- Location: Blackwater Valley A331/A325/B3272
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
What is it with DfT and their reluctance to designate new motorways?
A link between two moorways is, err, an APDC?
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Sorry, I meant "Non-Motorway Traffic" or NMT
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
If HE budget was that vast we wouldn't have an at grade solution being pushed in the first place.Chris5156 wrote: ↑Fri Jul 30, 2021 08:15This is true, but not good enough any more, IMO. Shared footpaths that are used for cyclists are a terrible compromise. HE has a vast budget and even dedicated spending for improvements to NMU provision; they should be working towards dedicated cycle facilities on all their schemes. That applies more than anywhere else in a situation like this where you’re going to see a whole junction ripped up and rebuilt - it’s an opportunity to make real improvements that won’t be repeated. Fail to provide properly for NMUs now and it will be difficult to ever add provision for them later.Patrick Harper wrote: ↑Thu Jul 29, 2021 21:31These sorts of schemes tend to make the footpaths shared use as well for those who are really scared.
The simple truth is, like most things in this country, the Government tries to do things on a shoestring (so it can claim to keep taxes low) while simultaneously diverting huge chunks of valuable taxpayers cash (which could be spent actually doing things) down the trousers of their outsourcing friends by stripping Government bodies of all expertise to do things in house.
HE have effectively been reduced to an uninformed commissioning agent with precious little engineering talent or vision within. They say to a contractor "this is the budget - go and give me a solution which can be built within it (with minimal landtake so we can minimise trouble from the neighbours / protest lobby)". Back comes the contractor with an at grade design festooned with traffic lights (and which they will claim makes the design NMU friendly) and some computer models which say it will just about work and the HE PR machine goes into overdrive about how wonderful they (HE) are for coming up with such a excellent design.
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
"The Secretary of State received the examining authority’s report on 21 July 2020 and the current deadline for a decision was 21 October 2021. The deadline is now extended to 21 April 2022."
https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/ ... ing-update
https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/ ... ing-update
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
I wish I could unilaterally extend all my work deadlines by six months whenever I felt like itjackal wrote: ↑Fri Oct 22, 2021 09:03 "The Secretary of State received the examining authority’s report on 21 July 2020 and the current deadline for a decision was 21 October 2021. The deadline is now extended to 21 April 2022."
https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/ ... ing-update
-
- Member
- Posts: 1481
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 07:52
- Location: Exits 9 & 10, M1 East, Melbourne, Australia
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
We should welcome any delay to such a poorly-designed scheme, as it's an opportunity for NH to have a last-chance change of mind and to make a better decision. Similarly with M25J10's delay.
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Any bigger / more comprehensive / superior / grade separated / etc scheme will cost a lot more than the current proposal.Peter Freeman wrote: ↑Fri Oct 22, 2021 10:19 We should welcome any delay to such a poorly-designed scheme, as it's an opportunity for NH to have a last-chance change of mind and to make a better decision. Similarly with M25J10's delay.
HM Treasury will NOT INCREASE THE ROADS BUDGET!
As such the more expensive you make this scheme, the less money there is for anything else - PLUS the BCR calculations will actually make the more expensive option look worse and thus something to be dropped completely!
As ever the REAL PROBLEM in this country is a combination is penny pinching (so as to keep taxes low) and a permanent focus on the short term / 'good enough' solutions which are just about deliverable by the current incumbents of Whitehall (and who can therefore claim the credit) rather than planning something that will function well for many decades to come.
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
My one real complaint with the scheme is the design for M6 J11 - basically it's just a bigger, wider, more signalised rbt. My suggestion is that it should rather be similar to the M54 J1 design, i.e., with the major movements to/from the M6 freeflowed and three small roundabouts to connect the other movements.Phil wrote: ↑Tue Oct 26, 2021 23:36Any bigger / more comprehensive / superior / grade separated / etc scheme will cost a lot more than the current proposal.Peter Freeman wrote: ↑Fri Oct 22, 2021 10:19 We should welcome any delay to such a poorly-designed scheme, as it's an opportunity for NH to have a last-chance change of mind and to make a better decision. Similarly with M25J10's delay.
HM Treasury will NOT INCREASE THE ROADS BUDGET!
As such the more expensive you make this scheme, the less money there is for anything else - PLUS the BCR calculations will actually make the more expensive option look worse and thus something to be dropped completely!
As ever the REAL PROBLEM in this country is a combination is penny pinching (so as to keep taxes low) and a permanent focus on the short term / 'good enough' solutions which are just about deliverable by the current incumbents of Whitehall (and who can therefore claim the credit) rather than planning something that will function well for many decades to come.
It's likely that this would cost a little more than the selected design. For instance, while it similarly requires two new bridges, one of them is significantly longer. Maybe £20m extra? But that's really a very minor cost compared to the benefit of making this motorway to motorway connection freeflowing rather than festooned with traffic lights in both directions.
It's extremely unlikely that this would result in the scheme getting cancelled. In fact the scheme would still be below the cost range of £250m-£500m indicated in 2014 - the current projection is £175m-£200m. (Yes, this is partly because the scheme no longer provides an M6T connection, but the bulk of the scheme was always M6 to M54, which is still being built.)
As Bryn says above, some consultants just can't design junctions. We shouldn't let them get away with it by assuming their hand is forced by the budget. There's zero evidence of that in this case.
General arrangement: https://infrastructure.planninginspecto ... 0Plans.pdf
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
This was given development consent by the SoS yesterday so it is a goer.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
The M25 - The road to nowhere
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Definitely better than the current A460 but the fact the GAs show four lane approaches to the M6 J11 roundabout suggests this'll be queued up from the start. A wasted opportunity.A303Chris wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:04 This was given development consent by the SoS yesterday so it is a goer.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
Bryn
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
- Steven
- SABRE Maps Coordinator
- Posts: 19384
- Joined: Tue Feb 12, 2002 20:39
- Location: Wolverhampton, Staffordshire
- Contact:
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
And I give it five years after it's open before it's completely surrounded by tin sheds with frontages. Not making it a Special Road is a really daft decision, but then given HE don't understand Special Roads at all.Bryn666 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:12Definitely better than the current A460 but the fact the GAs show four lane approaches to the M6 J11 roundabout suggests this'll be queued up from the start. A wasted opportunity.A303Chris wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:04 This was given development consent by the SoS yesterday so it is a goer.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
But then most of the traffic queues are caused by the traffic lights in Featherstone, so at least there's that.
Steven
Motorway Historian
Founder Member, SABRE ex-Presidents' Corner
Add your roads knowledge to the SABRE Wiki today!
Have you browsed SABRE Maps recently? Try getting involved!
Motorway Historian
Founder Member, SABRE ex-Presidents' Corner
Add your roads knowledge to the SABRE Wiki today!
Have you browsed SABRE Maps recently? Try getting involved!
-
- Member
- Posts: 1481
- Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 07:52
- Location: Exits 9 & 10, M1 East, Melbourne, Australia
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Two brand new 4-lane bridges over the M6 and still woefully poor at that end.
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
The access arrangements make it harder for the tin sheds to obstruct the new road but the old road is going to be ripe for it, that green wedge between old and new will be infilled very quickly.Steven wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:15And I give it five years after it's open before it's completely surrounded by tin sheds with frontages. Not making it a Special Road is a really daft decision, but then given HE don't understand Special Roads at all.Bryn666 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:12Definitely better than the current A460 but the fact the GAs show four lane approaches to the M6 J11 roundabout suggests this'll be queued up from the start. A wasted opportunity.A303Chris wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:04 This was given development consent by the SoS yesterday so it is a goer.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
But then most of the traffic queues are caused by the traffic lights in Featherstone, so at least there's that.
Thankfully this can't happen on the A556 because of the green belt. M6 J19, unlike J11, doesn't have the potential to seriously jam up even before the works were completed for the cut throughs.
Bryn
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
That’s “stacking space”, so thankfully those vehicles stopped at a junction aren’t in a queue, they are simply “stacked”. Which is obviously much better.Bryn666 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:12Definitely better than the current A460 but the fact the GAs show four lane approaches to the M6 J11 roundabout suggests this'll be queued up from the start. A wasted opportunity.A303Chris wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:04 This was given development consent by the SoS yesterday so it is a goer.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
Chris
Roads.org.uk
Roads.org.uk
Re: M54 Extension and M6 Toll/M42 Jct Improvements announced
Ah yes, like the good old theme park queues that aren't queues, they're interactive exhibits whilst you wait...Chris5156 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:46That’s “stacking space”, so thankfully those vehicles stopped at a junction aren’t in a queue, they are simply “stacked”. Which is obviously much better.Bryn666 wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:12Definitely better than the current A460 but the fact the GAs show four lane approaches to the M6 J11 roundabout suggests this'll be queued up from the start. A wasted opportunity.A303Chris wrote: ↑Fri Apr 22, 2022 10:04 This was given development consent by the SoS yesterday so it is a goer.
Really needed, real faff getting from the M6 toll to the M54 at present and I still use the M6 through Birmingham when heading to the M54 from the M40.
Bryn
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck
Terminally cynical, unimpressed, and nearly Middle Age already.
She said life was like a motorway; dull, grey, and long.
Blog - https://showmeasign.online/
X - https://twitter.com/ShowMeASignBryn
YouTube - https://www.youtube.com/@BrynBuck